Kemi Badenoch ripped into Andy Burnham over the soaring benefits bill during a fiery PMQs today. The Tory leader asked the Prime Minister if he was going to cut welfare during the current parliament.
It comes as measures recommended in a new report commissioned by the Government to tackle the youth unemployment crisis will not save money for a decade.
Mrs Badenoch told the Commons: “I asked him if he was going to cut the welfare bill this Parliament. I think it sounds very clearly like he is not.
“He talks about a landmark report. He isn’t planning any savings for 10 years. Those young people aren’t going to be young in 10 years’ time. Everything he wants to do takes 10 years.
“He wants a 10-year plan, still not ready, by the way. NATO defence plan, 10 years. Now it’s going to take him 10 years to make any welfare savings. We can’t wait 10 years, those young people need those jobs now.”
Andy Burnham accused of misleading MPs over Brexit
Andy Burnham has been accused of misleading MPs over Brexit, after campaigners said official figures show British exports are now higher than before Britain left the EU.
The Stay Out campaign, backed by Lord Gove, demanded the Prime Minister return to the Commons and correct the record.
It came after he clashed with Kemi Badenoch at Prime Minister’s Questions over his plans to cosy up to Brussels.
The campaign says the Government’s own data shows Britain sold £190billion more to the world in 2025 than in 2019, its last full year in the bloc.
Andy Burnham Brutally Torn Apart by Kemi Badenoch in Fiery PMQs Attack
Andy Burnham has faced one of his most uncomfortable confrontations in the House of Commons after Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch launched a fierce attack on his handling of welfare reform, youth unemployment and the growing financial pressures facing Britain.
The Prime Minister was left defending his government’s position after Badenoch highlighted apparent contradictions between his public statements and the recommendations of a major report into Britain’s youth unemployment crisis.
The fiery exchange at Prime Minister’s Questions on 18 November 2026 exposed serious questions about Labour’s economic priorities and whether Burnham can deliver meaningful welfare reform without leaving vulnerable people worse off.
Badenoch arrived at the despatch box determined to put the Prime Minister under pressure. Rather than allowing him to hide behind general promises about supporting young people, she demanded clear answers about the government’s plans to reduce welfare spending.
Her attack quickly developed into a wider challenge to Labour’s credibility.
For Burnham, the confrontation was particularly important because his government is already facing difficult questions over public spending, economic growth, immigration and its controversial plans to reset Britain’s relationship with the European Union.
The Conservative leader appeared determined to demonstrate that the Prime Minister’s promises were not matching the reality of his policies.
Badenoch puts Burnham on the spot over welfare spending
The confrontation began when Badenoch asked whether Burnham would commit to reducing Britain’s welfare bill during the current Parliament.
The question was deliberately direct.
Britain is facing substantial pressure on public finances, with welfare spending representing one of the major challenges confronting the Treasury.
The Prime Minister responded by promising that he would do everything possible to bring the welfare bill down as quickly as possible.
He also referred to the recently published report by former Labour minister Alan Milburn, which examined the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training.
Burnham argued that the report provided an important opportunity to rethink how the government supports younger generations.
He announced that he had asked Cabinet colleagues to reprioritise spending plans for 2027–28 to begin establishing funding for a proposed Youth Opportunity Service.
However, Badenoch was not satisfied.
She wanted to know when the promised savings would materialise and whether Labour was prepared to make difficult decisions to reduce welfare expenditure.
Her argument was that the government could not continue promising reform without explaining how it intended to pay for it.
The Milburn report creates an embarrassing contradiction
The most damaging moment came when Badenoch highlighted an apparent contradiction between two interviews given by Burnham and Alan Milburn.
During an interview with Sky News, the Prime Minister had insisted that he did not want anybody to lose money as a consequence of the government’s welfare changes.
However, Milburn, the author of the report, had been asked whether the proposed reforms could be implemented without some young people receiving less money.
His answer was straightforward: “No, you can’t.”
Badenoch used the conflicting statements to challenge the Prime Minister directly.
She pointed out that Burnham had suggested nobody would lose out, while the report’s author acknowledged that some people would receive less financial support.
She then demanded to know which of them was telling the truth.
It was a difficult question for the Prime Minister because it went to the heart of the government’s welfare proposals.
If some young people are expected to receive less money, ministers must explain who will be affected and how vulnerable individuals will be protected.
Burnham attempted to shift the discussion towards the broader objectives of the reforms.
He insisted that the government was focused on helping young people into employment and providing them with better opportunities.
But Badenoch’s intervention had exposed an important weakness: the public needs clear answers about the financial consequences, not simply promises about long-term ambitions.
<Cite refs={[“turn170741search1″,”turn170741search2”]}/>
Burnham hits back with an attack on the Conservatives
The Prime Minister refused to allow Badenoch to dominate the exchange.
He accused the Conservative leader of failing to understand the challenges facing young people and criticised what he described as her party’s reliance on spending cuts.
Burnham argued that the biggest increase in young people not in education, employment or training had occurred between 2022 and 2024, when the Conservatives were in government.
He also accused the previous administration of cutting youth services and removing opportunities from younger generations.
In one of his strongest responses, he said:
“She reveals time and time again when she comes to that despatch box, why she doesn’t understand this issue.”
He continued by accusing Badenoch of only ever asking for cuts.
The Labour benches responded enthusiastically, with MPs cheering the Prime Minister’s more combative performance.
Badenoch, however, refused to back down.
She responded that the person who did not understand the situation was Burnham himself.
The exchange demonstrated a significant change in the Prime Minister’s approach to PMQs.
Rather than relying entirely on prepared statements and avoiding direct confrontation, Burnham appeared more willing to challenge his opponents personally.
<Cite refs={[“turn170741search0″,”turn170741search4”]}/>
Youth unemployment is becoming a major political problem
Behind the Westminster confrontation lies a serious economic challenge.
The number of young people not in education, employment or training has become an increasingly important issue for policymakers.
Young people who remain outside employment and education for extended periods can face serious long-term disadvantages.
They may struggle to develop professional skills, gain qualifications and establish financial independence.
The consequences can extend throughout their working lives, increasing the likelihood of long-term unemployment and dependence on government support.
Milburn’s report has therefore called for a different approach to helping young people enter employment.
The proposed Youth Opportunity Service is intended to provide more coordinated support, helping individuals access training, employment opportunities and other assistance.
Burnham believes that investing in young people now could reduce future welfare costs and improve Britain’s economic performance.
However, the government faces a difficult financial balancing act.
It must provide enough support to help disadvantaged young people while demonstrating that welfare reforms will produce genuine savings.
Badenoch’s criticism reflects the Conservatives’ argument that Labour cannot solve the problem simply by announcing new programmes and promising additional investment.
The government must demonstrate measurable results.
Badenoch turns the argument towards Labour’s economic credibility
The Conservative leader’s wider political strategy is to portray Labour as a government struggling to reconcile its promises with financial reality.
Burnham has promised to improve public services, support vulnerable households and stimulate economic growth.
At the same time, the government faces pressure to reduce public expenditure and control the welfare budget.
These objectives are not necessarily incompatible, but they require difficult decisions.
Badenoch wants voters to question whether Labour has a realistic plan for achieving them.
Her challenge over the Milburn interviews was particularly effective because it focused on a specific disagreement rather than simply exchanging political accusations.
If the government accepts that some young people will receive less financial support, it must explain why.
If it insists that nobody will lose out, it must explain how the reforms will deliver the savings ministers say they want.
Without clear answers, Labour risks losing public confidence in its welfare programme.
Brexit and the European reset add another challenge
The PMQs confrontation also comes at a particularly difficult time for Burnham.
His plans to reset Britain’s relationship with the European Union have generated considerable controversy among Conservative MPs and Brexit supporters.
The government believes closer economic cooperation could reduce trade barriers, improve food exports and strengthen Britain’s economic prospects.
However, opponents have warned that the proposals could involve significant financial commitments and greater regulatory alignment with Brussels.
Badenoch has repeatedly criticised Labour’s European strategy, arguing that Britain must not become a country that follows European rules without having an equivalent voice in making them.
The Prime Minister is therefore dealing with several political challenges simultaneously.
He must defend his welfare reforms, explain his economic strategy and reassure voters that closer European cooperation will not undermine Britain’s democratic independence.
These issues provide the Conservatives with opportunities to question whether Labour has a coherent long-term plan.
A more combative Prime Minister emerges
One of the most interesting aspects of the confrontation was Burnham’s noticeably stronger performance.
Political commentators observed that the Prime Minister had previously tended to adopt a relatively restrained approach during PMQs.
This time, however, he appeared more energetic and willing to engage directly with Badenoch’s criticisms.
Labour MPs welcomed the change, particularly when he accused the Conservatives of damaging opportunities for younger generations during their time in government.
The Scotsman described the performance as Burnham’s punchiest PMQs appearance yet.
Nevertheless, a more aggressive parliamentary style does not automatically solve the government’s policy problems.
The Prime Minister must still answer questions about the welfare reforms, the financial implications and the potential impact on young people.
Winning an argument in the Commons is one thing. Delivering successful reforms across the country is considerably more difficult.
<Cite refs={[“turn170741search4″,”turn170741search0”]}/>
Conclusion: Badenoch has exposed a difficult test for Burnham
Kemi Badenoch’s fiery attack has placed Andy Burnham under renewed pressure to explain exactly what his welfare reforms will mean for ordinary people.
Her most effective intervention concerned the apparent contradiction between the Prime Minister’s promise that nobody would lose money and Alan Milburn’s acknowledgement that some young people would receive less.
It was a direct challenge that Burnham could not simply dismiss by attacking the Conservatives.
The government now needs to explain how it intends to reduce welfare spending, support young people into employment and protect those who genuinely cannot work.
Badenoch has also demonstrated that the Conservatives intend to scrutinise every inconsistency in Labour’s economic promises.
For Burnham, the political danger is clear.
He cannot promise lower welfare spending, greater financial protection and improved opportunities for everyone without explaining how those objectives will work together.
The Prime Minister may have shown a more combative side at PMQs, but the real battle will take place outside Westminster.
British voters will ultimately judge him not on how loudly he responds to Badenoch, but on whether his government can deliver economic improvements without breaking its promises to the people who need support most.
