Andy Burnham’s claim that Britain’s economy has suffered as a direct result of leaving the EU has been torn apart by figures released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS).
According to productivity data, the UK has outperformed all of its counterparts in the bloc, only trailing behind the US on output per hour among G7 countries since 2015.
The figures emerge just days after Andy Burnham delivered a speech at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet amid the Government’s push for closer ties with Brussels.
Claiming the UK had “lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years”, the Prime Minister told attendees: “Taken as a whole, the OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) says Brexit has meant a four per cent hit to the British economy.
“Others put it higher at up to eight per cent of GDP.”
Before Britain formally withdrew from the EU, the Treasury watchdog warned such a move could slash “potential productivity” of the UK economy by four per cent after 15 years.
But the fresh ONS data suggests the economy has been more efficient than previously believed.
By updating the way they measure how much workers produce per hour, researchers found that since 1997, the UK has grown faster than Germany, France, and Italy.
The UK held onto that lead over the last 10 years – meaning only the US beat Britain’s efficiency growth among the world’s seven largest advanced economies.
Upon releasing the figures, the ONS said: “While international comparability between productivity growth rates should be treated with some caution, because of differences in measurement methodology, the UK’s growth since 1997 being the second highest among this group suggests that productivity growth over the past three decades has been stronger than previously perceived.
“However, it is still materially lower than that observed in the US.”
Simon French, chief economist at Panmure Liberum, said the data presents “a rather awkward data backdrop” to Friday’s UK-EU summit in Brussels.
He wrote on social media: “It now reveals that since the Brexit vote in 2016 the UK’s productivity performance has accelerated away from comparable EU economies – having largely tracked them (2016-2025) in the previous iteration of this data.
“It must call into question the validity of the (widely cited) NBER estimate that Brexit triggered a three per cent to four per cent reduction in UK productivity.
“We have consistently believed the Brexit impact to be closer to half this level.”
On Friday, the Prime Minister will seek to lock in deals on food, emissions trading and youth mobility at the gathering in Brussels.
At Mansion House earlier this week, Mr Burnham “if we are going to be serious about growth” there must be a “conversation” surrounding closer alignment with the EU.
“It’s like the emperor’s new clothes, where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth.
“Well, I do try to say things as I see them, and to be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years. The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain.”
He also argued that a new agreement with the bloc may bolster economic growth, warning against turning its back on the potential benefits of a closer partnership.
“We are not in a position to turn our back on a potential deal that could add up to 0.4 per cent to GDP,” he said.
The Great Rejoiner Myth Exposed as Official Figures Blow Apart Andy Burnham’s Brexit Claim
The debate over Britain’s future relationship with the European Union has returned to the centre of British politics, with Andy Burnham facing growing questions over his claims about the consequences of Brexit. Supporters of leaving the EU argue that the promises made by the Brexit campaign have been unfairly criticised, while opponents insist that Britain has suffered economically and politically since ending its membership. As new figures and competing economic assessments enter the debate, the question is whether calls for rejoining the European Union are based on convincing evidence or political nostalgia.
Andy Burnham has increasingly opened the door to discussing Britain’s possible return to the European Union. Although he has acknowledged that rejoining is not an immediate proposal, his comments have created a fresh political controversy. For many supporters of Brexit, the idea that Britain should reconsider its decision represents an attempt to reverse a democratic choice made by millions of voters in the 2016 referendum.
However, the discussion is more complicated than some political headlines suggest. Burnham has expressed a desire to see Britain return to the EU during his lifetime, but he has also acknowledged that the country is not ready to begin the process immediately. He has suggested that different relationships with Europe should be considered, including closer economic cooperation and potentially full membership in the longer term.
This distinction matters because discussing rejoining is not the same as announcing that Britain will rejoin. No decision to reverse Brexit has been made, and any future application would involve extensive negotiations, political agreement, and a clear assessment of the conditions offered by the European Union.
What Do the Figures Actually Tell Us About Brexit?
One of the biggest disagreements concerns the economic consequences of leaving the EU. Critics argue that Brexit has damaged trade, investment, productivity, and economic growth. Supporters counter that these arguments frequently rely on comparisons with hypothetical economic scenarios rather than directly measurable losses.
A particularly important example is the estimate that Britain’s economy could be between 6 and 8 per cent smaller by 2025 than it would have been if the country had remained in the European Union. This estimate has been associated with economic modelling by researchers at the National Bureau of Economic Research.
However, such a figure does not represent money directly removed from the British economy or an independently measured annual Brexit bill. It compares actual economic performance with an alternative scenario representing what might have happened without Brexit.
That distinction is central to the argument. Economic models depend on assumptions, comparisons, and predictions. They can provide useful evidence, but they cannot establish with absolute certainty what Britain’s economy would have looked like under different political circumstances. The pandemic, international energy prices, inflation, and global economic developments have also influenced Britain’s performance.
Brexit supporters therefore argue that politicians should avoid presenting hypothetical economic losses as unquestionable facts. They believe the public deserves a more balanced assessment that considers both the costs and potential benefits of independence from EU institutions. <Cite refs={[“turn350408search1″,”turn350408news9”]}/>
The £750 Million-a-Week Controversy
Another issue attracting attention is the financial argument surrounding Britain’s possible return to the EU.
The anti-rejoin campaign group Stay Out has promoted an estimate suggesting that membership could cost Britain approximately £750 million per week, equivalent to around £39 billion annually.
The figure has become a major talking point among opponents of rejoining. They argue that Britain should carefully consider whether returning to the European Union would justify such a substantial financial commitment.
However, there is an important qualification. This is a campaign estimate based on particular assumptions about future membership terms, rather than an established bill confirmed by an independent government assessment.
The actual financial arrangements would depend on negotiations, including Britain’s contributions, potential rebates, participation in EU programmes, and the economic benefits associated with membership.
Nevertheless, the financial question deserves serious consideration. British taxpayers would expect the government to explain the costs of any proposed agreement and demonstrate how the country would benefit.
The argument should not be reduced to a single headline figure. Both the costs of membership and the economic consequences of remaining outside the EU need to be examined carefully. <Cite refs={[“turn350408search0″,”turn350408search1”]}/>
Have British People Really Changed Their Minds?
One of the strongest arguments made by supporters of rejoining is that public opinion has shifted considerably since the 2016 referendum.
Recent YouGov research published in June 2026 found that 57 per cent of Britons believed the decision to leave the EU had been wrong, while 55 per cent supported rejoining.
At first glance, these figures appear to provide a powerful argument for reconsidering Brexit.
However, another finding reveals a more complicated picture.
When respondents were told that rejoining could mean losing some of the special arrangements Britain previously enjoyed, including potential opt-outs relating to the euro and Schengen, support fell to approximately 35 per cent. Opposition increased to 43 per cent.
This demonstrates that supporting the general idea of rejoining is not necessarily the same as accepting the actual conditions that might accompany membership.
Many people may favour closer cooperation with Europe without wanting Britain to surrender additional powers or accept arrangements they previously rejected.
For politicians such as Burnham, this represents a significant challenge. Winning public support for closer relations is one thing. Convincing voters to accept the practical consequences of full membership could be considerably more difficult. <Cite refs={[“turn350408search6″,”turn350408search3”]}/>
Brexit Was About More Than Economics
The 2016 referendum was never exclusively about trade figures or economic forecasts.
For millions of Leave voters, the central issues included national sovereignty, democratic accountability, immigration control, and the authority of British institutions.
They believed important decisions affecting the United Kingdom should be made by elected representatives in Westminster rather than by institutions based in Brussels.
For these voters, Brexit represented an opportunity to establish a different relationship with Europe while allowing Britain to develop its own policies.
Supporters also argued that leaving would give the country greater flexibility when negotiating international trade agreements and establishing domestic regulations.
However, these promises also created expectations that successive governments have struggled to satisfy. Britain’s economic performance, immigration figures, and political disagreements have ensured that Brexit remains a controversial subject.
The challenge for Brexit supporters is therefore to demonstrate tangible advantages rather than relying exclusively on arguments about sovereignty.
Equally, opponents must explain precisely how returning to the EU would address Britain’s economic problems without introducing new financial and political difficulties.
Burnham Faces a Difficult Political Balancing Act
Andy Burnham’s position is particularly sensitive because Brexit continues to divide the British electorate.
A substantial proportion of Labour voters support closer relations with Europe, and some would welcome a future commitment to rejoining.
A poll reported by The Independent in October 2026 found that nearly three-quarters of Labour voters wanted Burnham to include discussions about rejoining the EU in the party’s next manifesto.
Nevertheless, Reform UK supporters and many traditional Leave voters remain strongly opposed to reversing Brexit.
Burnham must therefore balance the expectations of pro-European voters against the concerns of people who believe the referendum result should be respected.
His political opponents are likely to use any suggestion of returning to the EU as an opportunity to question his commitment to democratic accountability.
The Prime Minister has also indicated that rejoining is not an immediate objective and that any future decision would require a wider public discussion.
This means the political argument is likely to continue for years rather than being settled through one announcement or one parliamentary debate. <Cite refs={[“turn350408search4″,”turn350408search2”]}/>
The European Union Would Also Have a Say
Another important factor often missing from political discussions is the position of the European Union itself.
Britain cannot simply announce that it wants to rejoin and automatically recover its previous membership arrangements.
Any application would involve negotiations with existing member states and would be subject to the EU’s accession procedures.
The conditions could differ significantly from those Britain enjoyed before Brexit. Questions surrounding budget contributions, regulatory alignment, freedom of movement, and participation in European institutions would all need to be addressed.
There is no guarantee that Britain would recover every previous exemption.
This creates a difficult question for rejoin campaigners: would they still support membership if the conditions were less favourable than those enjoyed before 2016?
The British public would need clear answers before being asked to consider such a major constitutional decision.
Britain Needs Facts Rather Than Political Slogans
Ultimately, the argument between Brexit supporters and rejoin campaigners demonstrates how difficult it is to separate economic evidence from political interpretation.
One side highlights trade barriers, weaker investment, and estimates of lost economic growth. The other emphasises national independence, democratic control, financial contributions, and the opportunities created by independent policymaking.
Neither side should be allowed to present selective statistics as the complete story.
Britain needs an honest assessment of its economic relationship with Europe, including the benefits of cooperation and the consequences of remaining outside the single market and customs union.
The government should also explain whether closer cooperation could achieve many of the desired economic improvements without requiring full EU membership.
That would allow voters to make an informed decision rather than being pushed into another divisive political argument based on fear or nostalgia.
Conclusion
The latest controversy surrounding Andy Burnham and Brexit demonstrates that Britain’s relationship with Europe remains far from settled. Claims that official figures have completely destroyed the case for rejoining deserve scrutiny, just as claims that Brexit has unquestionably cost Britain a specific amount of money must be examined carefully. Economic modelling, financial estimates, and opinion polls all provide useful information, but none should be interpreted without considering their assumptions and limitations. Britain has already made a historic decision to leave the European Union, and reversing that decision would require substantial political, economic, and legal negotiations. Andy Burnham must explain exactly what closer European relations would mean for British taxpayers, businesses, workers, and national sovereignty. Ultimately, the future should be determined through transparent debate, reliable evidence, and democratic consent. The British public deserves more than another political battle between Leave and Remain. It deserves an honest explanation of what would make Britain stronger, more prosperous, and better prepared for the future.
