The Chagos Islands “surrender” deal cleared its final Commons hurdle on Monday night, paving the way for the territory to be formally handed to Mauritius by the end of this year.
MPs voted through the Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill on its third reading by a 320-171 margin shortly before 11pm – following a testy debate in the chamber.
Reform UK’s Danny Kruger had raised fears of a “secret deal with China” lying behind the handover deal as he warned just how “baffling” the decision to give the islands away would be.
Nigel Farage had separately warned that China was moving to buy one of the islands.
In response to Mr Kruger, Foreign Office Minister Stephen Doughty crowed in response: “Why then does the United States, our Five Eyes partners, or other key allies, support this deal?
“It protects our national security, it secures the base on Diego Garcia. Why would they support it? It’s no secret deal. It’s absolute nonsense.”
The deal, if it passes the Lords, will see the British Indian Ocean Territory formally ceded to Mauritius.
Britain will then pay to rent back Diego Garcia, the archipelago’s largest island and home to a joint UK-US military base.
PICTURED: US Air Force ground crew members wave at a B-52H Stratofortress bomber as it taxis in Diego Garcia for take off on a strike mission against Afghanistan in October 2001
GETTY
The 99-year deal to lease the UK-US Diego Garcia base is set to cost British taxpayers up to £30billion – more than double Mauritius’s annual GDP.
Though analysis by the Taxpayers’ Alliance suggested the cost could be even higher, at £47billion.
The Tories had tabled amendments to the Bill which would have blocked payments for Diego Garcia unless they were approved by Parliament, and forced the Government to consult exiled indigenous Chagossians further on the handover..
While Mr Farage said China was “negotiating a lease on Peros Banhos, the island close to Diego Garcia”.
Stephen Doughty claimed the deal ‘protects our national security and secures the base on Diego Garcia’
HOUSE OF COMMONS
The Reform chief specifically named UK national security adviser Jonathan Powell as the architect of the deal – and accused him of “selling us out to China”.
And he threatened that, as Prime Minister, his Government would not honour the treaty.
“I would put it that this deal is un-British, he said. “It’s against our national interest. There is no upside, there is no gain.”
Across the Atlantic, allies of Donald Trump had also raised the alarm over the Chinese threat.

Nigel Farage specifically named UK national security adviser Jonathan Powell as the architect of the deal – and accused him of ‘selling us out to China’
PA
Diego Garcia is a submarine refuelling and resupply station, as well as a hub for satellite communications in the region, making the island a significant strategic base for the Royal Navy.
Mauritius enjoys a close relationship with Beijing, prompting critics to warn that China will try to undermine the base by spying on its operations.
However, the deal includes so-called “security guarantees” which would prevent any foreign military installations on outlying islands near Diego Garcia without the consent of the British Government.
And immediately following the deal’s announcement in May, China’s ambassador to Mauritius, Huang Shifang, said Beijing “fully supports” Mauritius in its “quest to safeguard national sovereignty”.
Chagos Islands Deal Passes in Commons – With Formal ‘Surrender’ Now Expected in Just Months
The controversial Chagos Islands agreement has triggered another major political storm in Britain, with opponents warning that the country is preparing to surrender an important overseas territory to Mauritius. The proposed deal, negotiated by Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s Labour government, would transfer sovereignty of the Chagos Archipelago while allowing Britain and the United States to continue operating their strategically important military base on Diego Garcia. The agreement has attracted fierce criticism from Conservative politicians and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage, who argue that Britain should not give up sovereignty over territory with such significant military and historical importance.
First of all, the Chagos Islands are located in the Indian Ocean, approximately halfway between Africa and Indonesia. Although the archipelago consists of numerous islands, Diego Garcia is by far the most strategically important because it hosts a major joint British-American military installation.
The military base has played an important role in international security for decades. Its geographical position allows the United States and Britain to support military operations across the Middle East, the Indian Ocean and parts of Asia.
It also provides facilities for aircraft, naval vessels, intelligence operations and logistical support.
Consequently, the future of Diego Garcia has become a major concern for British and American defence officials.
The controversy began with negotiations between Britain and Mauritius over the sovereignty of the archipelago.
Mauritius has long argued that Britain unlawfully separated the Chagos Islands from its territory in 1965, shortly before Mauritian independence in 1968.
The dispute became increasingly significant after the International Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion in 2019 stating that Britain’s continued administration of the islands should end as rapidly as possible.
Following years of diplomatic negotiations, the British government reached an agreement with Mauritius on May 22, 2025.
Under the proposed arrangement, Mauritius would gain sovereignty over the entire Chagos Archipelago, while Britain would retain rights to operate the Diego Garcia military base through an initial 99-year agreement.
The government has argued that the deal provides long-term legal certainty and protects an essential military installation.
However, critics have questioned why Britain should transfer sovereignty while continuing to pay Mauritius for access to the military base.
According to the agreement, Britain would make annual payments averaging approximately £101 million in today’s money, with the overall estimated cost reaching around £3.4 billion over the initial 99-year period. <Cite refs={[“turn282890search8″,”turn282890search1”]}/>
For Nigel Farage, the arrangement represents an unacceptable loss of British sovereignty.
The Reform UK leader has repeatedly attacked Starmer over the agreement, describing it as a surrender of British territory.
Farage believes that Britain should retain control of the islands and has promised that Reform UK would not accept the agreement as a settled matter if the party entered government.
He has also questioned whether the interests of the Chagossian people have been properly represented during negotiations.
Meanwhile, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has also criticised the agreement, raising concerns about its financial implications and potential consequences for Britain’s national security.
Opposition politicians argue that the government should reconsider the arrangement rather than commit taxpayers to substantial payments over several generations.
However, the Labour government maintains that the agreement is necessary to protect the future of Diego Garcia.
Ministers have argued that continued legal uncertainty could eventually undermine the military base and create opportunities for other countries to increase their influence in the region.
Another important issue concerns the Chagossian people themselves.
Between the 1960s and 1970s, approximately 1,400 to 1,700 Chagossians were removed from their homeland to make way for the military installation.
Many were relocated to Mauritius and the Seychelles, where their descendants have continued campaigning for recognition, compensation and the right to return.
The proposed agreement includes provisions allowing Mauritius to facilitate resettlement on some of the islands, although Diego Garcia itself would remain unavailable for ordinary civilian resettlement while the military base operates.
This has created further disagreements among Chagossian campaigners, with some supporting the agreement and others believing that their community has not been adequately consulted.
Nevertheless, the political situation has changed significantly during 2026.
Following Donald Trump’s withdrawal of support for the agreement, the British government placed the parliamentary ratification process on hold.
In September 2026, Defence Secretary Wes Streeting confirmed that the government was reviewing the deal after the American president again criticised its terms.
The government has maintained that the agreement cannot proceed without sufficient American support because of the importance of the Diego Garcia military installation. <Cite refs={[“turn282890search0″,”turn282890news13”]}/>
The original headline suggesting that the deal had passed the Commons and that formal surrender was expected within months therefore needs an important qualification: the original implementing legislation did not complete its passage through Parliament, and the treaty has not entered into force.
Indeed, the House of Commons Library confirmed in October 2026 that the implementing bill had fallen when the previous parliamentary session ended.
A separate British Sovereignty Protection Bill has also been introduced in the House of Lords, proposing additional protections for British sovereignty and requiring the consent of the Chagossian people before any future transfer. <Cite refs={[“turn282890search1″,”turn282890search5”]}/>
The situation has therefore become considerably more complicated than a straightforward parliamentary approval.
For Keir Starmer, the agreement represents a difficult diplomatic challenge. The Prime Minister must balance Britain’s relationship with Mauritius, the security interests of the United States and the concerns of opposition politicians.
He must also demonstrate that the government is protecting British national security while addressing the historical injustice experienced by the Chagossian population.
Meanwhile, Reform UK has used the controversy to reinforce its message about national sovereignty and the importance of protecting Britain’s overseas territories.
Farage argues that the country should not surrender strategically important territory without a compelling reason and a clear democratic mandate.
However, any future government seeking to reverse the agreement would face significant diplomatic and legal challenges.
The dispute is not simply about which country owns a group of islands. It concerns international law, historical responsibility, military cooperation and the rights of a displaced population.
Ultimately, the future of the Chagos Archipelago will depend on whether Britain, Mauritius and the United States can reach an arrangement that addresses their competing interests.
In conclusion, the Chagos Islands agreement has become one of the most contentious foreign policy issues facing Britain. Keir Starmer’s proposed transfer of sovereignty to Mauritius has attracted fierce criticism from Nigel Farage, Kemi Badenoch and other opponents who believe the country should retain control of its overseas territory. Although the original agreement provides for continued British-American military access to Diego Garcia for at least 99 years, the financial cost and historical consequences remain controversial. Furthermore, the withdrawal of American support has placed the agreement on hold, meaning that formal sovereignty transfer is not currently imminent. The rights of the Chagossian people must also remain central to any future settlement. Ultimately, the government faces the difficult task of protecting national security, respecting international law and ensuring that historical injustices are not ignored in the pursuit of a diplomatic agreement.
