Three Labour police and crime commissioners have published a pro-migrant “fact sheet” in a bid to “promote compassion” for new arrivals to Britain.
Durham, Northumberland and Cleveland PCCs have teamed up with pro-immigration organisation The North East Migration Partnership (NEMP) to create the leaflet.
The document, which is set to be handed out to libraries and community centres in the areas, claims it dispels “common myths” surrounding the behaviour of migrants in Britain.
The NEMP is funded by the Home Office and Department for Levelling Up, Housing, and Communities.

The leaflet features nine ‘myths’ surrounding ‘harmful’ attitudes against migrants
The groups website claims it “provides support to migrants” and “helps make sure the region can benefit from migration”.
The leaflet features nine “myths” surrounding “harmful” attitudes against migrants, including that the new arrivals are a “drain our public resources”.
It argues that it is “quite the opposite”, adding that migrants contribute more to public finances than the average British citizen.
The document reads: “The Office of Budget Responsibility estimates that the average migrant, who moves to this country at the age of 25 and lives until 80, will contribute £341,000 to public finances over the course of their lives.
“That’s more than a British citizen contributes on average.”
However, the OBR admitted last year that low-paid migrants are a net drain, costing taxpayers £150,000 by the time they reach the state pension age.
The document also indicates there is “no evidence” that “migrants bring crime to our streets”, and even goes on to suggest “there could be a link between waves of immigration and falling crime rates”.
It adds: “In fact, various studies have found that neither asylum seekers nor other types of migrants could be linked to significant changes in violent crime.”
According to court records, asylum seeker hotel occupants have been charged with a total of 435 offences, 109 relating to violence and 44 for sexual offences, including alleged rape.
According to court records, asylum seeker hotel occupants have been charged with a total of 435 offences
The pro-migrant leaflet also claims that “it is just not true” that “all migrants are given preferential access to social housing”.
The police chiefs claim that “migrants are less likely to get social housing than people born in the UK”.
However, almost half (48 per cent) of all of London’s social housing is taken up by foreign-born heads of households.
The documents also goes on to claim that “most” migrants who arrive to Britain “know nothing about welfare benefits before they arrive” and therefore, “they have no expectation that they will receive financial support”.
Durham Police and Crime Commissioner Joy Allen said: “We know that misinformation fuels fear and can lead to hate crime.
“This initiative is about stopping harmful narratives in their tracks and promoting compassion and truth across our region.”
Northumbria PCC Susan Dungworth said: “Time and time again online and in the media we’re all being fed harmful myths.
“All this incorrect information isn’t just misinforming us, it’s dividing us too.”
“We came together on this project because we all want to set the record straight – replace the fiction with the facts – and hate with understanding.”
Cleveland Police and Crime Commissioner Matt Storey added: “We must do all we can to get the reality of the situation regarding immigration into the public domain and challenge those divisive voices.”
Labour Police Chiefs Publish Pro-Migrant ‘Fact Sheet’ in a Bid to ‘Promote Compassion’ for New Arrivals
Three Labour-linked Police and Crime Commissioners have sparked a political controversy after publishing a pro-migration information leaflet designed to challenge negative perceptions of migrants and asylum seekers in Britain. The document, titled ‘Migrant Myth Busters’, aims to promote compassion and understanding by addressing common claims about immigration, crime, welfare benefits and social housing. However, the initiative has attracted criticism from those who believe that police authorities should concentrate on public safety rather than promoting what they consider to be a particular political position on immigration.
First of all, the controversial leaflet was produced through a collaboration between the Police and Crime Commissioners for Durham, Northumbria and Cleveland and the North East Migration Partnership (NEMP).
The three commissioners involved were Joy Allen, Susan Dungworth and Matt Storey. They explained that the purpose of the publication was to challenge misinformation and reduce hostility towards migrant communities.
The two-page document reportedly addresses nine common claims about migrants and attempts to provide information that challenges negative stereotypes.
It is intended to be distributed through libraries, community centres and other public locations across the North East of England.
According to its supporters, the initiative is necessary because inaccurate information about immigration can contribute to prejudice, discrimination and hate crime.
Joy Allen, Durham’s Police and Crime Commissioner, argued that misinformation could create fear and division within communities.
She explained that the campaign was intended to replace harmful narratives with accurate information and encourage greater understanding between different groups.
Susan Dungworth, the Northumbria commissioner, also defended the project, arguing that incorrect information circulating online and through the media could divide communities.
Meanwhile, Cleveland commissioner Matt Storey said that the public needed access to reliable information about immigration and asylum.
However, the initiative has generated criticism because of the political sensitivity surrounding immigration in Britain.
One of the most controversial sections concerns the economic contribution made by migrants.
The leaflet challenges the suggestion that migrants place an excessive burden on public finances. It cites an estimate from the Office for Budget Responsibility suggesting that an average migrant arriving at the age of 25 and remaining in Britain until the age of 80 could make a positive lifetime contribution of approximately £341,000 to public finances.
The publication argues that migrants can contribute significantly through employment, taxation and economic activity.
Nevertheless, the economic impact of immigration is complicated and varies considerably according to factors such as income, age, employment status and length of residence.
Not every migrant makes the same contribution, and different categories of migration can have very different fiscal consequences.
Therefore, the figures should not be interpreted as meaning that every individual migrant automatically provides the same financial benefit to the country.
Another important section of the leaflet addresses concerns about crime.
The commissioners argue that there is no convincing evidence that migrants as a whole increase crime rates in Britain.
The document refers to research suggesting that immigration and violent crime do not have a straightforward relationship. It also highlights studies indicating that immigration has not necessarily produced increases in violent offences.
This is an important distinction because migrants are not a single, uniform population. Their backgrounds, circumstances and experiences vary enormously.
However, critics argue that discussions about immigration and crime should also acknowledge individual criminal cases, safeguarding failures and concerns involving asylum accommodation.
The public deserves accurate information about offending, regardless of whether suspects are British citizens, foreign nationals, refugees or asylum seekers.
It is equally important to recognise that allegations are not the same as convictions and that crime statistics must be interpreted carefully.
The leaflet also challenges the belief that migrants receive preferential access to social housing.
According to the commissioners, migrants are generally less likely to access social housing than people born in the United Kingdom.
The document attempts to explain that access to housing and welfare support depends on immigration status, eligibility requirements and individual circumstances.
Asylum seekers, for example, are subject to different legal arrangements from people who have received refugee status or permanent permission to remain in Britain.
The publication also addresses misconceptions about welfare benefits, explaining that many migrants do not have automatic access to the benefits available to eligible British residents.
These distinctions are important because public discussions about immigration frequently combine different groups under one general label.
However, the leaflet has prompted questions about whether the commissioners have presented a sufficiently balanced picture of the challenges facing local communities.
Britain is currently experiencing considerable pressure on housing, healthcare and public services. Many residents are concerned about the availability of affordable accommodation, NHS waiting times and the financial implications of supporting people seeking asylum.
These concerns should not automatically be dismissed as prejudice or misinformation.
At the same time, economic and social pressures cannot fairly be attributed to migrants without examining the wider causes, including housing shortages, public spending decisions and long-term planning failures.
The North East Migration Partnership has also attracted attention because it receives public funding.
The organisation works with local authorities and other partners to support migrants and help the region respond to migration-related issues.
Its involvement in producing the leaflet has led some critics to question whether organisations promoting migration support should be involved in information campaigns associated with police commissioners.
However, the commissioners maintain that the partnership has relevant experience and knowledge of migration issues.
The central question is whether the document provides sufficiently balanced and evidence-based information to help residents understand a complicated subject.
The political implications are particularly significant for Keir Starmer’s Labour government.
Immigration has become one of the most difficult issues facing the Prime Minister, especially as the number of people arriving through irregular Channel crossings continues to attract public attention.
Labour has promised to strengthen border security, dismantle people-smuggling networks and improve the efficiency of the asylum system.
At the same time, the government has faced criticism from opposition parties that believe it has failed to reduce irregular migration quickly enough.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has repeatedly used immigration as a central issue in his political campaigns, arguing that Britain needs stronger border controls and a more effective deportation system.
Conservative politicians have also questioned Labour’s ability to manage immigration and protect public confidence.
Against this background, the publication of a leaflet encouraging compassion towards migrants could become another source of political disagreement.
Supporters argue that tackling prejudice is an important responsibility for public institutions, particularly when hate crime threatens community safety.
Critics, however, believe that police commissioners should avoid appearing to take sides in wider political debates.
Police organisations must maintain public confidence across all sections of society. Their responsibilities include protecting victims, investigating crime and ensuring that everyone receives equal treatment under the law.
They must also be able to communicate accurate information about issues that affect public safety.
There is nothing inherently wrong with challenging misinformation. However, public information campaigns must be transparent about their sources, methodology and limitations.
Economic estimates should be properly explained, crime statistics should be presented in context, and legitimate concerns about public services should be addressed rather than ignored.
Ultimately, Britain’s immigration debate requires honesty from politicians, public authorities and the media.
People should be able to discuss immigration policy openly without being labelled racist simply for raising questions. Equally, migrants and asylum seekers should not be collectively blamed for crimes or problems for which they are not responsible.
A fair society must protect both freedom of debate and the dignity of individuals.
In conclusion, the decision by three Labour-linked Police and Crime Commissioners to publish the ‘Migrant Myth Busters’ leaflet has reignited controversy over immigration, public safety and the role of police authorities. Joy Allen, Susan Dungworth and Matt Storey argue that the initiative will challenge misinformation, reduce hate crime and promote compassion towards newcomers. However, critics believe that public institutions must ensure their information campaigns remain balanced and acknowledge the genuine pressures facing British communities. The debate demonstrates how deeply divided Britain remains over immigration and national identity. Ultimately, the country needs accurate statistics, transparent public policies and constructive discussion rather than political hostility. Protecting migrants from discrimination and addressing legitimate concerns about immigration are not mutually exclusive. Both should remain essential priorities for a fair, safe and democratic Britain.
