Fraudster Kashim Chowdhury’s conviction for holding down five full-time jobs shows just what a basket case the Civil Service has become. His contracts totalled 183 hours a week – more hours than actually exist in seven days – but his colleagues failed to notice. Either this means each of those five jobs could actually have been done in one day or no one cared that the work wasn’t getting done.
Actually, managers did think he was useless but failed to take action. Perversely, on one occasion, they still went ahead and gave him a permanent contract despite believing his work was “exceptionally poor” and he was incapable of completing basic tasks. Prosecutors said he “exploited” the work-from-home culture in the Civil Service that meant he rarely had to ever meet anyone in person. One video call to discuss illness descended into farce when Chowdhury, an Asian man, wore white make-up so he would look unwell.
As the call continued, it started to melt away, revealing his natural colouring on his forehead. Yet still he carried on, clawing in thousands of pounds a month in taxpayers’ cash. He earnt £350,000 from eight employers in less than three years and in May 2023, he was being paid for five full-time jobs at the same time.
Chowdhury started at Tower Hamlets Council in February 2020, then took a second job with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in April 2021, with the roles overlapping for more than a year.
He went on to hold down jobs at East London NHS Trust, the Department of Health and Social Care, the UK Health Security Agency, the Department for Business and Trade, the Food Standards Agency and the Home Office.
The manager who recommended that Chowdhury pass probation admitted he had done the “bare minimum” but he was given the benefit of the doubt. Defra’s policy meant that fixed-term employees were made permanent unless they had gone through formal performance measures.
Chowdhury kept his camera off during most work meetings so it was impossible to know what he was actually doing while the calls were carried out. Few would survive in the private sector if they were so woefully underperforming, but the civil service has a job for life culture.
At Southwark Crown Court yesterday, Chowdhury, 56, from Whitechapel, east London, was found guilty of nine counts of fraud Southwark Crown Court. He was caught not because investigations were carried out into his appalling work, but because a public sector data-matching exercise threw up an alert.
The case is an extreme example, but not the only one, of so-called “polygamous workers” discovered in the Civil Service. Since 2016 more than 300 employees have been caught holding multiple public sector jobs. But the issue is far wider reaching than public sector employees going as far as committing fraud. There are many highly skilled, committed and driven employees employed by the state, but they are dragged down by the lethargic civil service culture. Working from home and flexi-time is now the default while a sick-note culture pervades.
After the pandemic, the Tories tried to get staff back into the office but were met with fierce resistance. Sickness rates remain far higher in the public sector than, with mental ill health the main cause. Chowdhury got away with his crimes for so long because the culture allowed him to.
If a private company operated like that, it would go bust. But there are no consequences for the Civil Service. It’s just taxpayers’ cash and there is plenty more where that comes from (especially under Labour) to pay for more staff to cover the work he was failing to do.
Alex Thomas, a former Defra director who now works at the Institute for Government think tank, believes civil service performance would be improved by using compulsory redundancies to shed a “relatively small number” of the lowest performing staff.
Thomas admitted that even the civil service’s “stoutest defenders” acknowledge it is “not very good at performance management” and said it was “near-impossible to actually dismiss anyone” for underperformance.
Cabinet Secretary Dame Antonia Romeo today gave a speech admitting the public has low levels of trust in the Civil Service and promised a “fundamental” overhaul.
She must start by ruthlessly weeding out underperformers, introducing incentives and ending the culture of turning a blind eye to failure. Anything less will mean taxpayers continue to be fleeced by employees who abuse the system.
Asian Fraudster Used White Make-Up to Fake Illness While Secretly Holding Down Five Jobs
A shocking fraud case has exposed serious weaknesses in Britain’s public sector employment controls after a civil servant secretly held multiple full-time government jobs, earned hundreds of thousands of pounds and allegedly used an extraordinary disguise to convince his manager that he was seriously ill.
Kashim Chowdhury, a 56-year-old man from east London, was found guilty of nine fraud offences at Southwark Crown Court after secretly working for several public sector organisations between 2020 and 2023.
At the height of the deception, he was being paid for five full-time positions simultaneously, with overlapping employment contracts demanding an astonishing 183 hours of work every week.
The total amount he received from his various public sector positions was approximately £350,000.
Perhaps the most bizarre detail emerged during evidence about a video meeting with his manager. Chowdhury was accused of applying white make-up to his face to make himself appear unwell during a discussion about his sickness absence.
However, the alleged disguise began to come off as he sweated, exposing darker skin underneath.
The case has raised serious questions about how one individual could maintain so many overlapping government positions without the organisations involved discovering what was happening.
The extraordinary five-job operation
Chowdhury’s employment history involved eight public sector organisations over approximately three years.
His positions included roles at:
- Tower Hamlets Council.
- The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra).
- East London NHS Trust.
- The Department of Health and Social Care.
- The UK Health Security Agency.
- The Department for Business and Trade.
- The Food Standards Agency.
- The Home Office.
These positions overlapped at different times, allowing him to collect multiple salaries simultaneously.
Prosecutors explained that Chowdhury had made false representations about his existing employment when applying for additional positions.
He allegedly failed to disclose that he was already working for other public sector organisations, allowing him to obtain further full-time contracts.
By spring 2023, his contractual working hours had reached 183 hours per week.
That figure is particularly extraordinary because there are only 168 hours in an entire week.
The prosecution argued that he exploited the widespread adoption of remote working during the COVID-19 pandemic to conceal his employment arrangements.
The white make-up incident that exposed the deception
One of the most remarkable moments in the case involved a Microsoft Teams meeting on May 4, 2023.
Aleesha Adams, his manager at the UK Health Security Agency, organised the meeting to discuss his sickness absence and arrangements for returning to work.
She told the court that she was surprised when Chowdhury appeared on screen wearing what she believed was white facial make-up.
He was reportedly coughing, blowing his nose and holding tissues towards the camera to demonstrate how unwell he was.
However, Adams noticed something unusual.
As the meeting continued, Chowdhury began sweating, causing the white substance on his forehead to separate and reveal darker skin underneath.
She told the court that the make-up appeared to be rubbing away, leaving a noticeable difference between his face and neck.
The prosecution suggested that the make-up had been deliberately applied to create the impression that he was ill.
Chowdhury denied wearing make-up and rejected the suggestion that he had deliberately attempted to deceive his manager during the meeting.
Nevertheless, the incident became an important part of the prosecution’s account of his alleged conduct.
The unusual video call also raised suspicions about his employment arrangements.
Adams subsequently discovered that Chowdhury had joined the meeting using an email address belonging to Defra rather than the UK Health Security Agency.
This discovery contributed to growing concerns about his activities.
Sick notes while continuing to work elsewhere
Prosecutors told the court that Chowdhury used sickness absence from certain employers to manage the impossible demands of his overlapping positions.
In March 2023, he was reportedly signed off sick from four organisations while continuing to work for the Home Office.
The prosecution argued that this arrangement allowed him to continue receiving income from different employers while avoiding some of his contractual responsibilities.
His managers also described problems with his performance.
Some colleagues complained about unfinished assignments, missed meetings and work that required substantial correction.
One manager described having to provide extensive guidance because Chowdhury was not completing tasks to the expected standard.
These concerns raise questions about why repeated performance problems did not trigger an earlier investigation into his employment arrangements.
The case eventually came to light through the government’s National Fraud Initiative, which identified suspicious employment information through data matching.
Defra subsequently launched an investigation, and Chowdhury was arrested in July 2023.
He was dismissed from the civil service in September 2023.
How much taxpayers’ money was involved?
The financial implications are among the most serious aspects of the case.
Chowdhury received approximately £350,000 in gross salary from eight public sector employers between February 2020 and September 2023.
The prosecution argued that the money had been obtained through dishonest representations about his employment circumstances.
The jury ultimately found him guilty of eight counts of fraud by false representation and one count of fraud by failing to disclose information.
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has condemned the conduct.
A departmental spokesperson said that Chowdhury had abused the trust placed in him as a public servant.
The department also indicated that it would pursue available avenues to recover the proceeds of his offending.
The case has intensified questions about whether public sector organisations have sufficient systems to identify employees holding multiple overlapping positions.
Although public sector employers carry out employment checks, the case demonstrates the importance of effective information sharing and regular monitoring.
Chowdhury’s explanation to the court
During the proceedings, Chowdhury denied acting dishonestly.
He suggested that previous experiences of insecure employment had influenced his decisions and that he feared losing his livelihood.
He also referred to personal stress and psychological difficulties, explaining that these circumstances affected his thinking when applying for additional jobs.
The court heard that he had previously experienced redundancy and had been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.
He also explained that his mother had been seriously unwell and that he needed to work from home to help care for her.
However, prosecutors argued that his circumstances did not justify concealing multiple full-time employment arrangements.
They maintained that he deliberately misrepresented his existing work commitments to obtain salaries from several public sector organisations.
After considering the evidence, the jury found him guilty of all nine fraud charges.
A wider problem for Britain’s Civil Service?
The case has prompted renewed discussion about the management of Britain’s public sector workforce.
Remote working expanded significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic, changing how government departments and public organisations supervised employees.
For many workers, flexible arrangements have provided valuable benefits, including reduced commuting costs and improved work-life balance.
However, the Chowdhury case demonstrates how inadequate monitoring and fragmented employment records can create opportunities for abuse.
The government has previously identified other cases involving public sector employees holding multiple jobs without appropriate disclosure.
The central issue is not remote working itself, but whether employers have effective systems for monitoring contractual responsibilities and identifying potential conflicts.
Public sector organisations need to balance employee privacy and flexible working arrangements with their responsibility to protect taxpayers’ money.
Better coordination between departments could help identify overlapping employment records before problems become serious.
A separate family dispute
Chowdhury has also faced a separate legal dispute involving his family’s property.
His siblings have alleged that he exerted undue influence over their seriously ill mother shortly before her death to obtain a larger share of the family home.
The property, located in east London, has reportedly been valued at approximately £2.1 million.
His siblings claim that their mother was extremely unwell and did not fully understand the documents she was signing.
They have also raised concerns about whether the documents were adequately explained in her native Bengali.
Chowdhury denies the allegations.
This is a separate civil matter and should not be confused with the criminal fraud convictions.
What happens next?
Following his conviction, Chowdhury was refused bail.
The judge indicated that he faced the possibility of a very significant custodial sentence.
The authorities are also considering the recovery of money obtained through the fraudulent employment arrangements.
The outcome of the sentencing process will determine the criminal penalty imposed for the nine offences.
Meanwhile, the case is likely to remain an important example in discussions about public sector accountability.
Conclusion: A scandal that raises serious questions about accountability
The Kashim Chowdhury case is an extraordinary example of alleged employment deception involving multiple public sector organisations.
Holding five full-time positions simultaneously, accumulating contractual hours exceeding the total available hours in a week and allegedly using white make-up to appear sick during a workplace video call have made the case particularly unusual.
But beyond the bizarre details lies a much more serious issue.
Public sector organisations are responsible for ensuring that taxpayers’ money is used properly and that employees fulfil the responsibilities for which they are paid.
The fact that Chowdhury was able to maintain overlapping positions across numerous organisations for such an extended period raises important questions about employment checks, management supervision and information sharing.
The government must examine how these failures occurred and whether existing safeguards are sufficient to prevent similar cases.
Remote working should not automatically be treated as a problem, nor should the actions of one individual be used to condemn thousands of dedicated public servants.
However, taxpayers have every right to expect transparency, accountability and effective management of public money.
Ultimately, the case is a reminder that public trust depends not only on the integrity of individual employees but also on institutions capable of detecting and preventing abuse.
The challenge now is to ensure that the lessons from this extraordinary fraud case lead to meaningful improvements across Britain’s public sector.
