Scottish independence chaos as nationalists demand Andy Burnham release secret data . hyn

Prime Minister Burnham Visits A Manufacturing Company In The Southwest Of England

The Cabinet Office has done polling on Scottish indepndence since Andy Burnham came to power (Image: Getty)

Ministers must publish unreleased documents on Scottish independence polling, the SNP has demanded. The Cabinet Office has conducted polling on the issue since Andy Burnham became Prime Minister, a Freedom of Information request has revealed.

Friend or foe? How Andy Burnham will deal with the SNP

The department has refused to publish the results of this.

Former SNP MP Tommy Sheppard, who has been involved in fighting for the UK Government to reveal results of previous unreleased polls, said: “I don’t have any objection to the Cabinet Office or the Government consulting the public to inform policy development.” Speaking to the Sunday National, he added: “But if they’re going to spend taxpayers’ money on doing that, then the taxpayer has a right to know what the results are.”

Mr Burnham at Prime Minister’s Questions in September said that the conditions for Scottish independence should be “exactly the same” as for Irish unification.

PM Andy Burnham says second Scottish independence referendum remains 'off limits'

 

At the time, Mr Burnham said that there would have to be “a clear consensus [and] I am not aware that there is a majority of public support for another referendum, and until that changes, there won’t be one”.

Mr Burnham’s official spokesman declined to explain what he had meant by a “clear consensus”.

In October, Mr Burnham was in Lanarkshire to make a “serious and genuine offer” to the Scottish Government to put more control “in the hands of local people” through devolution.

After that speech, the Prime Minister was again asked about Scotland’s path to independence. He said: “I just feel we all have to move beyond the constitutional questions.”

Mr Sheppard said: “Burnham talks all the time about transparency in government and the Government not being centralised, autocratic and remote from the people. So, if that’s true, then how can he possibly justify using taxpayers’ money for policy development research and not releasing the results?

Scottish independence - Wikipedia

“He’s said that if there was growing support for independence, then it would be proper to look at another referendum. So, if he’s asking the question, I think we all have a right to know what the answer was.”

SNP MSP Calum Kerr has demanded the results and documents on the polls be published in full, with the costs having also been concealed by the UK Government.

He said: “The UK Labour Government must publish these documents and results in full, and you can only conclude that their unwillingness to disclose the costs demonstrates this programme of research must be extensive.

“Poll after poll shows independence is the preferred position of the Scottish people. Three out of four nations in the UK are led by pro-independence First Ministers, and the British Prime Minister has agreed it is for the people of Scotland to decide our own future.

Fury as Andy Burnham hints at allowing second Scottish independence referendum - AOL

“It is no wonder this behind-closed-doors Whitehall operation is in place.”

This is not the first time a UK Government has done extensive polling on Scottish independence using public money and refused to publish the results.

Between January 2018 and May 2019, the then-Conservative UK government spent at least £264,807 hiring polling companies to research public attitudes to the Union.

The government’s refusal to publish the results triggered a long-running legal battle spearheaded by former SNP MP Sheppard, founder of the The Stand comedy clubs in Edinburgh and Glasgow.

A government spokesman said: “The UK Government regularly commissions research across the UK to help understand peoples’ priorities, and ensure the delivery of public services. The Prime Minister strongly believes in the Union, and does not support another referendum on Scottish independence.”

Andy Burnham dodges question on second Scottish independence vote - AOL

Miliband as Foreign Secretary Was a Mistake – Now He’s Burning Labour Down

The appointment of Ed Miliband as Foreign Secretary has sparked considerable political debate within the Labour Party, raising questions about the government’s priorities, its leadership strategy and the direction of Britain’s foreign policy. Once regarded as one of Labour’s most experienced political figures, Miliband has returned to the centre of government in a role that carries enormous responsibility. However, his appointment has also created controversy, particularly among critics who believe that his political approach could deepen divisions within the party at a time when unity and public confidence are essential.

Miliband was appointed Foreign Secretary on 20 July 2026, having previously served as Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero. His move represented a significant change in responsibilities, taking him from domestic energy policy to the complex world of international diplomacy. According to the official government record, he is now responsible for the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office and the government’s wider international priorities. His previous experience includes serving as Labour leader between 2010 and 2015 and holding senior ministerial positions under earlier Labour governments. Nevertheless, experience alone does not guarantee success in one of the most demanding positions in British politics.

The criticism surrounding his appointment reflects broader concerns about the Labour government’s political direction. Some opponents argue that Miliband’s political identity is closely associated with environmental policy and ideological debates about the transition away from fossil fuels. They question whether the same political approach can be successfully transferred to foreign affairs, where decisions frequently require difficult compromises involving national security, international trade, military cooperation and diplomatic relationships.

Supporters, however, point to his experience in government and his understanding of international climate diplomacy. They argue that climate change is no longer simply an environmental issue but an important component of international security, economic development and global cooperation. From this perspective, Miliband’s background could offer Britain an opportunity to strengthen its influence in international discussions about energy security and sustainable development.

One of the most important questions concerns the relationship between his previous responsibilities and his new position. As Energy Secretary, Miliband championed the transition towards cleaner energy and supported the government’s ambition to transform Britain’s electricity system. His agenda included expanding renewable energy, attracting investment in clean technology and reducing the country’s dependence on fossil fuels.

These objectives attracted both support and criticism. Environmental organisations welcomed the ambition, while some business representatives and political opponents expressed concerns about implementation costs, employment in traditional energy industries and the possibility that the transition could place additional pressure on households. The debate became particularly sensitive as energy bills remained an important concern for millions of families.

For Labour, these disagreements created a difficult political balancing act. The government wanted to demonstrate its commitment to environmental protection while reassuring workers, businesses and consumers that economic growth and affordable energy would not be sacrificed. Critics argued that the party had sometimes struggled to communicate how its environmental ambitions would translate into immediate improvements in people’s lives.

Miliband’s departure from the energy department therefore did not automatically resolve the disagreements surrounding his policies. Instead, those debates became part of the wider political legacy he carried into the Foreign Office.

His appointment also raises questions about the government’s understanding of international diplomacy. The Foreign Secretary must maintain relationships with major powers, respond to international conflicts, defend British interests and work with allies on issues ranging from trade to security. These responsibilities demand careful judgement and the ability to navigate situations in which Britain’s interests may conflict with those of its partners.

Miliband has outlined a commitment to defending democracy, freedom and the rule of law internationally. In his statement following his appointment, he also referred to his family’s experience as Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi persecution, explaining that their history had influenced his understanding of Britain’s role in the world. Such personal experiences may shape a politician’s perspective, but the effectiveness of foreign policy ultimately depends on decisions, diplomatic outcomes and the government’s ability to maintain consistent international relationships.

Another significant challenge concerns Britain’s relationship with the United States and European partners. International politics has become increasingly complicated by geopolitical competition, security concerns, economic uncertainty and disagreements over trade. Britain must maintain strong relationships with its traditional allies while protecting its own national interests.

The Foreign Secretary will also face difficult questions surrounding conflicts in the Middle East, the war in Ukraine, instability in Africa and the future of international development. Each issue requires a different combination of diplomacy, humanitarian assistance and strategic planning. A statement of principles is important, but the government must demonstrate how those principles can be translated into practical results.

Within Labour, the appointment has also revived discussions about the party’s internal balance of power. Miliband is an established political figure with a history of leadership ambitions and considerable influence among sections of the Labour movement. His presence in a senior Cabinet position could strengthen one political perspective while creating concerns among colleagues who favour a different approach.

However, describing the situation as Miliband personally destroying Labour would be an oversimplification. Political parties rarely experience serious difficulties because of one individual alone. Their problems usually develop through a combination of leadership decisions, economic pressures, policy disagreements, communication failures and public expectations.

Labour’s challenge is to maintain a coherent identity while governing in difficult circumstances. The party must demonstrate that it can manage the economy, improve public services, protect national security and respond to international developments. It must also explain its priorities clearly enough that voters understand what the government is trying to achieve.

The transition from opposition to government has historically created difficulties for political parties. Campaign promises must eventually be translated into policies, budgets and practical decisions. These decisions inevitably produce disagreements, particularly when financial resources are limited and competing demands cannot all be satisfied immediately.

Miliband’s political position could become part of this wider debate. If his foreign policy priorities are seen as disconnected from domestic concerns, critics may argue that Labour is concentrating too heavily on international ambitions while ordinary citizens remain worried about living costs, housing, healthcare and employment. Conversely, if his diplomacy strengthens Britain’s international relationships and supports economic cooperation, the government may present his appointment as an important contribution to national interests.

There is also an argument that foreign policy and domestic prosperity should not be treated as separate subjects. International trade, energy security, climate agreements and geopolitical stability all have direct consequences for British businesses and households. A successful Foreign Secretary must understand these connections and ensure that diplomatic decisions support the country’s wider economic and security objectives.

The question is therefore not simply whether Miliband was the right person for the position. It is whether the government has established clear priorities and an effective system for delivering them. The Prime Minister must ensure that the Foreign Secretary’s work complements the responsibilities of other departments rather than creating conflicting messages or competing political agendas.

Accountability will be essential. Parliament, journalists and the public should examine the government’s diplomatic decisions, assess its international commitments and question whether promised results are being achieved. Miliband should be judged on measurable outcomes rather than assumptions about his political identity or the controversies associated with his previous role.

Ultimately, the appointment represents both an opportunity and a considerable test for Labour. Miliband brings substantial political experience, an established international profile and a strong interest in climate and development issues. At the same time, his new responsibilities expose him to a different set of challenges that cannot be managed through domestic political arguments alone.

Whether his appointment strengthens or weakens the government will depend on the decisions made during his time at the Foreign Office. The Labour Party must also confront its own internal disagreements and demonstrate that it can deliver a consistent programme of government.

The headline claim that Miliband’s appointment was a mistake and that he is burning Labour down expresses a powerful political criticism, but it remains an interpretation rather than an established fact. The more important test is whether his actions produce tangible diplomatic achievements, protect Britain’s interests and contribute to a stable government.

For Labour, the stakes are considerable. Public confidence depends not only on political personalities but also on the government’s ability to deliver results. Miliband now has an opportunity to demonstrate that his experience can serve the country in a different capacity. If he succeeds, his appointment may be remembered as a strategic decision. If serious failures emerge, however, the criticism will become increasingly difficult for Labour’s leadership to ignore.

In the end, the future of Labour will not be determined by one minister alone. It will depend on collective leadership, political discipline, economic performance and the government’s ability to convince the public that it understands their priorities. Miliband’s tenure as Foreign Secretary will undoubtedly form an important part of that assessment.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *